Screen and Recoat vs. Refinishing: Which Does Your Hardwood Floor Need?

When a hardwood floor starts looking dull and worn, there are two very different fixes. A screen and recoat renews the finish on top of the wood. A full sand and refinish takes the floor down to bare wood and starts over. Picking the right one saves money and downtime, and recoating at the right time can keep you from ever needing the bigger job.

Quick Answer: Recoat or Refinish?

  • Screen and recoat when the finish is dull, scuffed or lightly scratched, but the wood underneath is not exposed.
  • Sand and refinish when wear has reached bare wood: gray or black areas, deep scratches, or water damage.
  • A recoat is faster, less disruptive and less expensive. A refinish is a bigger project with longer downtime.

See how each works ↓

What a Screen and Recoat Involves

A screen and recoat (sometimes called "buff and coat") works only on the finish layer:

  1. The floor is thoroughly cleaned to remove soil and residue.
  2. The top layer of finish is lightly abraded with a floor machine and a sanding screen or abrasive pad. This roughs up the surface so the new coat can bond.
  3. All dust is removed by vacuuming and tacking.
  4. A fresh coat of compatible finish is applied and left to dry and cure, following the product's directions.

Because it never cuts into the wood, a recoat can be repeated many times over the life of a floor.

What Full Sanding and Refinishing Involves

A refinish removes all of the old finish and a thin layer of wood. Then stain, if wanted, and several new coats of finish are applied. It fixes problems a recoat can't, like deep scratches and worn-through areas. But it takes longer, creates more dust and disruption, and removes wood each time. That matters most on engineered hardwood, which has a limited wear layer that can only be sanded a certain number of times.

How to Tell Which Your Floor Needs

  • Recoat: dull traffic lanes, light surface scratches, scuffs that stay in the finish, and uneven sheen.
  • Refinish: gray, black or bare-looking wood in traffic areas, deep gouges, stains that went into the wood, or boards damaged by water.

A quick check: sprinkle a few drops of water on a worn area. If the water beads up, the finish is still protecting the wood and a recoat will likely work. If it soaks in quickly and darkens the wood, the finish has worn through in that spot.

Hardwood floors in St. Louis?

We clean and protect hardwood in offices, lobbies, restaurants and retail spaces. See our hardwood floor care.

Get a Free Quote

Why Some Recoats Fail

A new coat of finish has to bond to the old one. Recoats can peel or show "fish-eyes" (small craters) when:

  • The floor was cleaned with oil soaps, polishes or "shine" products that left a residue.
  • The floor has a wax finish, which most modern finishes won't stick to.
  • The existing finish is a very hard factory finish that needs special prep before recoating.

That's why the finish should always be checked first, and why everyday cleaning products matter. See how to clean commercial hardwood floors for products to avoid.

How Often to Recoat Commercial Hardwood

It depends on traffic. Busy lobbies, restaurants and retail floors often need a recoat every one to three years. Quiet private offices can go much longer. The goal is to recoat while the finish is still intact. Once wear reaches the wood, a recoat is no longer enough.

Key Takeaways

  • A screen and recoat renews the finish; a refinish sands into the wood.
  • Recoat when wear is only in the finish. Refinish when bare wood shows.
  • Recoating on time can delay or prevent a full refinish.
  • Residue from oil soaps and polishes is a common cause of recoat failure.

Not sure which your floor needs? Bel Cleaning checks hardwood floors during a free walkthrough. Learn more about our hardwood floor cleaning and recoating in St. Louis.

BC
Bel Cleaning Editorial Team OSHA-compliant janitorial specialists • 15+ years in commercial cleaning

Ready for Professional Commercial Floor Cleaning?

Get a free, no-obligation quote for commercial floor cleaning tailored to your facility's size, type, and schedule. Bel Cleaning responds within one business day.